Google Reviews Are More Important Than You Think: Dean's Story
If you’d rather watch than read, check out the video version of this story here: Watch the Video
Running a business is tough.
You can do great work for years, have hundreds of happy customers, and still one single bad Google review can feel like a punch in the gut. The scary part? That one review could scare off your next ten potential customers before they even call you.
That’s exactly what happened to Dean, who runs a heavy vehicle workshop in Brisbane. When I caught up with him, he was still frustrated about an unfair review left months earlier.
Dean’s Story: A Bad Review From Someone He Didn’t Even Serve
Dean is straight‑up and professional.
He knows trucks, he knows the industry, and his regular customers trust him.
One day, a lady who had just bought a second‑hand truck rang him up on the phone. She wanted to know what repairs might be needed.
Dean gave her an honest warning, which is worth highlighting on its own:
“Lady, that model’s a nightmare. They’re expensive to repair, and that’s probably why you got it cheap in the first place… I hope you’ve got deep pockets!”
That single line sums up Dean’s no‑nonsense character and straight‑talking style.
That was it.
He hadn’t done any work, hadn’t charged them a cent—just gave advice over the phone.
Instead of being grateful, the caller took offense. They went straight to Google and left him a one‑star review with a scathing comment. Suddenly, anyone searching for Dean’s workshop saw that bad review front and centre.
Dean was gutted. He felt robbed.
He had no chance to fix it, no fair shot at defending himself, and no way to explain that he never even worked on the truck.
If you’re a small business owner, you can probably imagine the sinking feeling he had.
Reviews Aren’t Just About Reputation—They Affect Your Ranking
Google reviews do two big jobs:
They feed Google’s algorithm, helping decide where your business shows up in local search results.
They build trust with potential customers before they even pick up the phone.
That means if you’re not steadily collecting reviews, you’re falling behind.
Even if your service is outstanding, if your competitor has triple the reviews, Google will give them more visibility, and customers will feel more confident clicking on them.
In other words, reviews don’t just reflect your reputation—they actively drive your future leads.
Why Most Businesses Struggle With Reviews
Here’s the honest truth: most business owners know reviews matter, but they don’t have a system for collecting them.
They're leave it up to chance.
A happy customer says thanks, and maybe—just maybe—they’ll go home and leave a review.
But most won’t.
Life gets in the way.
Meanwhile, the few unhappy customers are motivated enough to go out of their way and post a bad one.
That’s why businesses often end up with reviews that don’t reflect reality. They might have hundreds of satisfied clients, but only a handful of reviews, leaving them exposed to damage.
The System You Need: Step by Step
The truth is, reviews don’t just happen—you need a system. And like any good system, it builds up in stages:
Ask directly – The most basic system is simply asking. As you wrap up a job, invite the customer to leave you a review. If you don’t ask, you don’t get.
Make it easy – Don’t leave it to chance. Give them a direct link or even a QR code they can scan on the spot with their phone. Put it on your business card, your counter, or a thank‑you note.
Automate the follow‑up – Send a quick text or email reminder with the review link. This nudges them while the good experience is still fresh in their mind.
Move to smart automations – Go further with smart tools that track who has left a review, send gentle reminders to those who haven’t, and route unhappy feedback to you privately before it goes public.
Bringing It Back to the 3 Pillars
If you’ve been following us for a while, you’ll know we always come back to our proven 3 Pillars of Local SEO Success:
Google Business Profile – Your foundation. If it isn’t set up and optimised, you’re invisible in local search.
Website Optimisation for Local Search – Your site must clearly show who you are, what you do, and where you do it, all in a way Google loves.
Online Reputation – Reviews, citations, and social proof. This is the fuel that powers everything else.
Dean’s story sits right here in Pillar 3. Without a steady flow of fresh reviews, even the strongest website and profile can be dragged down.
Dean’s Turning Point
When I explained this to Dean, you could see the lightbulb go on.
He realized the bad review wasn’t the end of the world. It was just a signal that he needed a better system. One that kept the flow of good reviews coming in—so his reputation wasn’t at the mercy of one angry person.
That’s when the conversation shifted from frustration to opportunity.
Instead of worrying about the bad review, he started planning for how to future‑proof his reputation.
WIIFM: What’s In It for You
If you’re a business owner reading this, here’s why this matters for you:
Protect your reputation: Don’t let one unfair review damage years of good work.
Boost your ranking: Google gives more visibility to businesses with fresh, consistent reviews.
Build trust instantly: Customers are more likely to choose you if they see dozens of happy reviews.
Create resilience: Bad reviews happen. But with enough good ones, they lose their power.
It’s not about perfection. It’s about consistency.
What Happens If You Don’t Fix This
Here’s the risk: if you ignore reviews, you’re leaving your business exposed.
Every time someone searches for your service, they’re comparing you against competitors. If your competitor has more reviews, they’ll look safer and more trustworthy, even if you’re the better option.
It’s like having a leaky bucket.
You can keep pouring in new leads, but if people are leaking out the bottom because of a weak reputation, you’re wasting time and money.
The Next Step: Build Your Review System
The truth is, you don’t need to handle this alone.
Setting up a system doesn’t have to be complicated, and once it’s in place, it runs in the background. That’s what we help businesses like Dean’s do every day. And it's more affordable than most people think - probably less than you spend on your coffee habit.
👉 Want to see how it could work for you? Book a free 20‑minute consult and we’ll walk you through what a review system could look like in your business. No pressure, just practical advice you can use.
Final Thought
Bad reviews happen. But they don’t have to define you.
With the right system, you can turn reviews from a liability into one of your strongest business assets.
